This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
| 3 minute read

Fortune favours the bold? SMCR reform: Phase Two

The FCA and PRA have published Phase Two of their reform of the Senior Managers and Certification Regime (“SMCR”), in Consultation Papers CP26/37 (FCA) and CP14/26 (PRA). These are the latest in a series of proposals designed to streamline individual accountability rules and reduce burdens on firms.

The regulators first consulted stakeholders on the regime's efficacy, scope and proportionality in a 2023 discussion paper as part of the government's Edinburgh Reforms, alongside a joint Call for Evidence by HM Treasury (“HMT”) on any legislative changes needed to rebalance the rules.

In 2025, the PRA and FCA launched their Phase One consultations alongside HMT’s legislative review. Phase One made short- to medium-term changes that did not require new legislation, with final rules and feedback published in April 2026. HMT also confirmed plans to amend FSMA to enable deeper reform, now reflected in the Financial Services and Markets Bill 2026 (“FSMB26”), which is currently before Parliament.

Phase Two is more structural: it explores which Senior Manager roles need pre-approval, the continued utility of the Certification Regime, and how conduct rule breach reporting should work going forward. Unlike Phase One, these changes depend on FSMB26 being enacted and commenced. Both regulators are pressing ahead now so they can finalise the regime as soon as the FSMA amendments take effect.

The consultations close on 22 January 2027.

Below is a list of the key proposals and main points firms with which firms may wish to engage during the consultation period, including key areas of divergence between the regulators.

Key proposals: a high-level summary

Senior Managers Regime: 

  • Introduce a "notified" tier of senior manager roles for which regulatory pre-approval is not required, with pre-approval being retained for only the most significant SMF roles;

  • Remove the SMF18/SMF22 (other overall/local responsibility) function for all firms;

  • Remove several of the prescribed responsibilities that need to be allocated to SMFs;

  • In relation to the SMF7 (group entity senior manager role), for the PRA, split it into a notified and a pre-approved function, and for the FCA narrow the scope of the role further;

  • Extend the 12 week rule for temporary / reasonably unforeseen SMF absences to 18 weeks;

  • Allow firms to apply for SMFs on a time-limited/conditional SMF approvals (rather than limits or conditions needing to be imposed by the regulator using statutory notices);

  • Raise the thresholds for enhanced firm status; and

  • Relax further the rules around filing and updating of statements of responsibilities and management responsibilities maps.

Certification Regime:

  • Both regulators propose scrapping the Certification Regime entirely, shifting responsibility for staff competence and suitability onto firms under their existing employee rules (the individual conduct rules will still apply to these individuals, but the initial and annual fitness & propriety process, regulatory reference regime and directory obligations are all proposed to be retired).

Conduct Rules: 

  • The statutory requirement to take all reasonable steps to ensure that staff subject to the conduct rules understand how those rules apply to them is proposed to be replaced with a regulatory obligation on the firm to notify all staff subject to the conduct rules of the rules that apply to them and the consequences of a breach.

  • The FCA proposes to raise the threshold for reporting conduct rule breaches by non-SMFs, in the case of disciplinary action, to where a final written warning or termination of employment has arisen; 

  • The FCA proposes to simplify and streamline breach reporting timelines.

Implementation is targeted for the second half of 2027, with final rules expected to be published six months in advance of becoming effective. This is contingent on the Financial Services and Markets Bill 2026 first being enacted and commenced.

Initial reactions

  • The Phase Two proposals are much more significant than Phase One and in a number of respects go further than was expected.

  • The proposed abolition of the certification regime is likely to have a mixed reaction. Removal of the prescriptive regime and reliance on a more principles based regime could lead to firms having to operate a shadow regime broadly equivalent to the current process, but without a regulatory underpin that ensures compliance and reduces the risk of divergent approaches across the industry.

  • The removal of the SMF18/22 roles will also likely prove controversial. For most large firms, these functions have provided important flexibility to ensure that SMF accountability and allocations reflect the reality of how the firm is organised and managed. Removal of those roles risks aggregating accountability and management responsibility in a smaller number of individuals but disconnecting the SMF allocation from the reality of how is in fact responsible for managing and reporting on the relevant business area or function to the CEO and the Board of the entity.

  • The FCA plans on dropping the requirement that an SMF vacancy be ‘reasonably unforeseen’ where a firm wishes to rely on the proposed 18-week temporary cover rule. The PRA maintains that an absence will still need to be temporary or reasonably unforeseen for temporary cover to be permissible for PRA functions at dual-regulated firms. This would mean different temporary cover requirements potentially applying within the same dual‑regulated firm. To mitigate this, the FCA suggests retaining the "reasonably unforeseen" test for dual-regulated firms (to preserve alignment with the PRA) as an alternative option.

  • Despite feedback on this point, neither consultation paper proposes to permit prescribed responsibilities to be allocated to an individual performing the SMF role under the 12/18 week rule.

 

Our proposals aim to maintain high standards of individual accountability and conduct while reducing unnecessary burden, making the regime more proportionate and easier to operate.

Tags

senior managers, smcr, uk, culture and conduct, enforcement